# Supplemental proof audit — issue24504

VERDICT: INSUFFICIENT overall: H remains open. A, C, E, G and the previously missing I cap subcase are SUFFICIENT within the explicitly synthetic capability scope. B, D, F, J retain the prior sufficient verdict supplied in the brief; no rebuild/core checks repeated.

Read-only inspection of the local supplemental bundle, its index/drivers/capability driver, and the original local matrix. Opened independently extracted 1 fps frames spanning all seven supplemental recordings, all seven tails, focused full-size transition frames, and 10 fps final-1.5-second sheets for H/I. No source review substituted for interaction proof. No server/browser, code edits, forge actions, push, merge or watch. Evidence targets requested pre-merge head203a30bacc; no post-merge rendering assertion.

| Row | Verdict | Observed supplemental proof / remaining gate |
|---|---|---|
| A | SUFFICIENT | caller-reset-dwell (15.611s): panel query205/select, Cancel, composer submenu/open at ~6s shows empty search and checked .env, 1 selected/15B; edit204/select, Cancel, panel submenu/open at ~13s restores same defaults. Tail actually contains reopened dialog. Closes alternate reset gap. |
| C | SUFFICIENT | selection-search-dwell at ~11–13s clears to initial list; ~14–15s blank-looking input has no placeholder and an offset caret, with initial list/.env retained, consistent with the documented whitespace-only action. This is materially distinct from the preceding empty clear. Exact three-space string comes from driver narration, not visible glyphs. Prior query/Enter/debounce proof retained. |
| E | SUFFICIENT | selection-search-dwell ~4s has only201 checked in six-result group plus hidden .env (2/23B); ~6s All yields7/63B; ~8s None yields1/15B. ~16–19s All200 then None0/no files. interactions ~72s has200 selected (oversize disabled + hidden205); ~73s None leaves1, ~74s search205 visibly checked. Closes partial-group and None-at-cap gaps. Optional zero-byte variant not added. |
| G | SUFFICIENT | selection-search-dwell ~9–10s no-match with1 selected/15B; ~11–12s clear restores checked .env and first200 list. Prior small/empty evidence retained. |
| H | INSUFFICIENT | service-failure-recovery (21.453s) visibly shows real missing-workspace error from ~12s onward with1 selected/15B and Clone enabled. This closes actual service-error/preserved-selection subcase. However, every sampled final1.5s frame and tail still displays failure-missing-cwd and red error: the claimed ~20s folder202 recovery is NOT in the retained recording. initial-refresh-failure (6.807s) ends in red error with cached1/15B and truncation hint; it does not prove cold initial failure/no invented defaults. Need controlled cold initial pending (Finding…/Clone disabled), controlled search pending (selection retained/Clone independent), fresh initial failure without cached defaults (error, zero invented selection, Clone enabled), and recorded search-error clear restoring original list. A new-query202 recovery alone would not satisfy the matrix clear-to-original requirement. Synthetic atom UI states are not controlled request lifecycle proof. |
| I | SUFFICIENT for known cap gap; synthetic scope only | legacy-exact200 (7.061s) ~4s shows200 selected/1.57KB, no search, first200 notice without search hint, cap message; ~5s None clears to no files. Driver changes SOURCE search capability only, keeps listing true and target search true. This satisfies the matrix-permitted explicitly synthetic capability branch and missing cap transition. Claimed ~6s repeat All restoring200 is NOT captured: tail/final1.5s remain empty with All. Correct narration or supply another recording if repeat is claimed. No actual old binary or >200-row old-server payload proven; neither should be advertised. |

Recording inventory also includes legacy-199-attempt (13.130s): honestly199 selected/1.56KB with oversize consuming a listing slot; not cap proof. interactions (87.005s) first ~55s largely troubleshooting/idle; its tail ends on the panel submenu, not a reopened dialog, superseded by dedicated A recording. selection-search-dwell is20.173s; its tail proves None/no-files. Caller reset is15.611s. Both error clips end on errors. No observed implementation defect asserted; findings concern proof completeness and two overclaimed video timestamps.

FRICTION: remote Markdown fetch failed (web tool inaccessible; curl DNS resolution failed), so original matrix and supplemental notes were read from supplied local evidence. Prior audit conclusions were inherited only as expressly supplied in the task, not claimed freshly fetched. Video timestamps in narration are approximate and two claimed final actions fall outside retained footage; tail inspection caught both. Generated inspection artifacts/report live only under /tmp. ghdrop upload attempted separately; result reported to parent.