# Final independent proof audit

PR [#24008](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/pull/24008). HEAD [f217759](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/commit/f21775904c4e1c647a0b4279f752013208694bb2), BASE [4812dca](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/commit/4812dcad02a86874533540e6a0c4b7f5eaea297a).

VERDICT: INSUFFICIENT A1-1440-light, A1-1440-dark, C1-1440-light, C1-1440-dark, C2-1440-light, C5-1440-dark.

All 24 published interaction recordings were opened and played to completion. Command/result/completed lifecycle and seeded resume-session matching were independently checked. C4 toggle and C5 settings/restoration exact frames were inspected beyond contact sheets. Interaction coverage is complete; the six wide visual comparison pairs remain incomplete. Continuous videos retain the differing source-control card state; documenting that difference does not satisfy matched-state visual rules. No non-AA hover/card mismatch is waived.

Original temporal still pairs were pixel-identical and separated by at least 500 ms. Independent unmasked difference counts appear below. Wide originals show mismatched source-control status cards. Retakes contain only wide A1 AFTER closed-card stills; neither corrected wide A1 pair is complete, and both corrected sides are absent for wide C1, C2 and C5. Six narrow cells have complete proof.

Independent A1 wide-light rebuild ran only after runtime release using r5 fixture/rebuild scripts. It completed the instructed command and reached completed idle. Its two independent stills differ by 509 pixels, so strict temporal settling fails. Against the delivered matched AFTER still: 491 pixels above zero, zero above threshold 16, maximum channel difference 3. These small differences are reported, not accepted or waived. This rebuild cannot repair missing BEFORE evidence.

CSS viewports were 1440x900 and 390x900, DPR2. Wide videos are 2880x1800; original wide still exports are 1280x800. Narrow stills/videos are 780x1800. Baseline replaces only the two changed files with pinned BASE versions in the otherwise current HEAD runtime, rather than running an entire BASE checkout.

Read-only L1/S1 source audit found the intended exact-command-boundary fix and unchanged surrounding gates. Supplied final focused tests report 45 passing; BASE with final tests reports 44 passing and the instructed-command regression failing. Independent planner cases also confirm whitespace/instruction handling. No additional source bug found. Synthetic offline peer exercises actual app composer/server SDK sequencing; this does not prove actual Claude restoration, summarization, billing or parser internals, native mobile, or remote/tunnel operation.

| Cell | Original unmasked pixels >0 / >16 | Final proof status |
|---|---:|---|
| A1-1440-light | 17136 / 3849 | Missing corrected BEFORE; AFTER-only retake |
| A1-1440-dark | 16835 / 3731 | Missing corrected BEFORE; AFTER-only retake |
| A1-390-light | 72207 / 9812 | Complete |
| A1-390-dark | 72157 / 9628 | Complete |
| C1-1440-light | 592 / 434 | Missing corrected BOTH sides |
| C1-1440-dark | 585 / 443 | Missing corrected BOTH sides |
| C1-390-light | 0 / 0 | Complete |
| C1-390-dark | 0 / 0 | Complete |
| C2-1440-light | 759 / 601 | Missing corrected BOTH sides |
| C3-390-dark | 0 / 0 | Complete |
| C4-390-light | 0 / 0 | Complete |
| C5-1440-dark | 585 / 443 | Missing corrected BOTH sides |


[Capturer public index](https://gh-file-drop-api-prod-mi5fy3sowv63ufte.pinglabs.workers.dev/f/efea767beb4899d9/public-index.md). [Capturer bundle](https://gh-file-drop-api-prod-mi5fy3sowv63ufte.pinglabs.workers.dev/f/990c0012863d4f22/final-capture-r5.tar.gz). [Source audit](https://gh-file-drop-api-prod-mi5fy3sowv63ufte.pinglabs.workers.dev/f/4e88a3e89e9b93b0/source-audit.md).

Independent integrity, inspected artifact hashes and rebuild comparison are supplied alongside this report. All owned runtime was stopped using retained handles; lead confirmed clean pinned HEAD and empty ports at 10:53 UTC. No source edits, commits, pushes, PR comments, CI polling or watchers. Deadline prevents further correction.

FRICTION
- Six corrected wide before/after pairs are incomplete.
- Independent A1 temporal settling fails strict pixel identity.
- Budget exhausted; no acceptance rule waived.

VERDICT: INSUFFICIENT A1-1440-light, A1-1440-dark, C1-1440-light, C1-1440-dark, C2-1440-light, C5-1440-dark.