# PR #22874 proof audit pass 2 (head b9d6319d60, before 8d3b061121)

| Row | Recordings ok | Narration matches | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | yes (BEFORE 70.9s, AFTER 115.3s) | yes | Frame-checked: AFTER 97s card resolved to "blue" and reply "You picked blue." with no provider; BEFORE 50s "blue" still in the composer and card unchanged |
| B | yes (21.1s / 52.7s) | yes | Frame-checked: Submit disabled on both sides; narration does not claim the click path is fixed |
| C | yes (5 files) | content yes; some times are wall-clock | VFR recordings; the outcome is in the last frame; identical on both sides |
| D1 | yes | content yes; BEFORE times are wall-clock | Blocked on both sides |
| D2 | yes (82.3s / 83.5s) | yes | Queued on both sides |
| E | yes (15.2s / 17.6s) | yes | Identical |

SHAs: /home/ubuntu/wt/pr-22874 = b9d6319d60, /tmp/ev-22874/before = 8d3b061121. Port 7702 is served from the head worktree; port 6205 from the before worktree.

Rebuild: row A on AFTER in a new synthetic thread (Claude Sonnet 5.5), with Claude and Codex disabled. The Submit pill was DOM-disabled (row B state); Enter submitted "blue" and Claude replied "You picked blue.".

VERDICT: SUFFICIENT