# Proof audit, pass 1 — 1Password account picker

Target: [#31721](https://git.cafe/pingdotgg/t3code/pull/31721) ([GitHub mirror](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/pull/31721)), fork [yordis/t3code](https://github.com/yordis/t3code), source branch `yordis/feat-onepassword-account-picker`, target `main`.
Pinned head: [8a7f0c086a](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/commit/8a7f0c086a3c22dbceadf5fb14bf95ca9ad949fa). Local branch `pr-31721`, read in `/home/ubuntu/wt/pr-31721`. PR metadata matched this head. Local main tip was [42a0e917cf](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/commit/42a0e917cf89df34b48c7106b7753e12830036a4), merge base [d929e726f2](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/commit/d929e726f223a3b76838ebbd839cce59e1ab0abe); comparison to the PR's stored main observation yields the same 13 changed paths. Scope is proof planning, not a merge-readiness verdict.

## Findings first

1. **No visual evidence exists yet.** Every affected fixture below is MISSING. No server/browser was started and no app capture, test run, edit, push, comment, or review was performed. All new files are under the allowed scratch directory; the target worktree was clean when inspected.
2. **Do not plan a filtered no-results screenshot.** The new field explicitly uses `mode="none"`; installed Base UI treats that as static suggestions and no inline completion. An unmatched typed account leaves all returned rows available. There is no Empty element, loading spinner, RPC-error banner, clear button, or saving-progress state in this dialog. It still accepts arbitrary valid shorthand/address/ID values and still caps the input at 253 characters.
3. **Cold fallback and cached fallback differ.** With no prior result, initial/pending/error states use `accounts.data ?? []` and hide trigger/popup. With previous successful data, query SWR and AsyncResult can retain suggestions during refresh or RPC failure. A CLI failure is instead a successful empty RPC response and removes them. These require recordings, not unrelated settled screenshots.
4. **The VM can reproduce real integration states with synthetic data.** There is no installed op or signed-in account. Put the supplied fake executable first on the *server* PATH. It supplies short/long/same-address/empty-email/overflow lists, nonzero exit, garbage/schema rejection, delayed response and timeout. An op stub cannot cause an actual RPC authorization/missing-method failure; those rows are explicitly labelled harness captures. Environment isolation also needs a harness here unless the capturer provisions a second isolated environment.
5. **Shared UI branches matter.** Under the default 640px `sm` breakpoint the dialog is a bottom sheet, buttons stack, inputs/items/trigger sizes change. Popup height is clamped to available space and 23rem, with a scrolling list and fades. Account and email both truncate. Light/dark border/background/invalid/highlight styles differ. A desktop-only happy-path still cannot prove these branches or interactions.
6. **No code defect is claimed from an uncaptured state.** Same-address rows are accepted by the driver; distinct user IDs produce distinct account values and rows keyed by those account values; F07 makes that data shape explicit. Capture the actual effect before alleging a visible regression. Existing bot statements about removed maxlength/read scope are stale: this head preserves maxlength and requires `providers:manage`.

## Render-path inventory

Only **one React component changes**: [SecretProviderDialog](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/blob/8a7f0c086a3c22dbceadf5fb14bf95ca9ad949fa/apps/web/src/components/settings/SecretProviderDialog.tsx#L34). The other changed production files add a query/RPC/schema/service/driver/authorization/instrumentation, not another visible component. All diff paths were read; relevant unchanged render dependencies were followed.

- **Every caller:** [EnvironmentSecretProviders inside SecretsSettings](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/blob/8a7f0c086a3c22dbceadf5fb14bf95ca9ad949fa/apps/web/src/components/settings/SecretsSettings.tsx#L181) is the sole mount. Add passes no `existing`; Edit passes an existing supported config. Settings nav, search, and direct navigation converge on `/settings/secrets`; there is no separate chat, command-palette, keybinding, MCP or native-mobile renderer of this field. Web and Electron use the same component. Native mobile has no Secrets page.
- **Every prop:** `existing` changes Add/Edit title, initialized name/account, button text and validation target; config label length wraps the title, account length scrolls/truncates the input; `existing.id` allows editing the current ID. `existingIds` affects only duplicate-name error in Add. `environmentId` selects the query/mutation destination and cache key; `environmentLabel` changes description wrapping. `onClose` causes unmount/remount and fresh draft/submitted state. No prop provides a disabled/read-only, loading, saving or theme variant inside this component.
- **State/validation:** fresh `submitted=false` suppresses errors and leaves submit enabled even for an invalid draft. Submitting flips it, shows zero/one/two error paragraphs, sets invalid input styles/description IDs, and disables submit while draft remains invalid. Fixing each field immediately clears its issue. Name messages are empty, invalid slug, duplicate ID, and schema-derived errors; ordinary typing is capped at 64. Account messages are empty, syntax failure, or max-length schema failure (last unreachable through ordinary capped input). A valid save sends settings patch and immediately closes; no local pending/success/error layout exists.
- **Accounts/data:** no data and successful empty array share the no-trigger/no-popup branch; all nonempty counts get a trigger and popup. Counts 1, 2 and enough to overflow differ geometrically. Each row is exactly bold account plus muted email, no checkmark or separator. Empty email is allowed; missing/non-string email invalidates the whole list. Repeated addresses are not deduplicated; all values use account as React key. Long text, including a schema-valid 253-character address, is truncated. No grouping, disabled/exhausted account state, sorting, filtering or account-type branch exists.
- **Async paths:** fresh/pending/error without previous data collapse visually to empty; positive result adds trigger; retained previous data stays visible while waiting or on RPC failure; successful [] removes it. There is no dialog refresh button. Query defaults are SWR revalidate-on-mount, 30s stale time and 5-minute idle TTL, without a periodic refresh option.
- **Interaction paths:** field click and trigger open; hover/keyboard highlight; click/Enter choose account string (email is display only); typing, paste, select-all/backspace clear, caret navigation and blur preserve free text. Clearing to blank and reopening are part of F05/F18/F25. Include arrows, Tab, Escape, outside click, trigger toggling, form Enter/submit, Cancel/X/backdrop dismissal, focus restoration, Edit/save/reopen and async replacement. No inline autocomplete is expected.
- **Presentation:** inherited [Autocomplete wrappers](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/blob/8a7f0c086a3c22dbceadf5fb14bf95ca9ad949fa/apps/web/src/components/ui/autocomplete.tsx#L10) provide input trigger, hover/highlight states, portalled popup, available-height/width collision behavior and ScrollArea fades. [Dialog](https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code/blob/8a7f0c086a3c22dbceadf5fb14bf95ca9ad949fa/apps/web/src/components/ui/dialog.tsx#L84) changes at `sm`; input focus/invalid states and light/dark styles are inherited. No new OS/browser/desktop bridge branch is introduced. Narrow **web** is required; it does not stand in for nonexistent native mobile UI. Coarse-pointer controls have larger hit targets; use touch on a narrow capture when available, otherwise identify it as narrow pointer-driven web.

## Capture legend and minimum set

Each row's capture column is the **minimum viewport × theme × fixture** set. `DL` = 1440×1000 light; `DD` = 1440×1000 dark; `NL` = 390×844 light; `ND` = 390×844 dark; `SL` = 844×390 light. Use explicit Appearance theme, not an unknown system setting, default app font size/zoom 100%. These samples cover both sides of the 640px branch, both themes, and a height-constrained popup. F08 may additionally resize across 639/640 inside its recording to check the transition. No full Cartesian product of all validation messages and theme/viewports is necessary because their shared style branches are covered by F14/F18/F19.

All F rows are required as listed, including harness labels where specified. One recording can cover multiple rows/keyframes at the same dimensions/theme, but its manifest must name them. `recording` means stills alone are insufficient; include the entire meaningful transition, with representative keyframes for the table. A static row can be a keyframe from another matching recording. Do not tick a cold-error row using a CLI-failure screenshot, or a timeout using a settled empty screenshot.

For before/after: obtain matched **Before** and **After** stills for F01/F02 at the actual common base and final reviewed head, with the same viewport/theme/form values. On the base the plain input has the old helper and no trigger. F03/F08 show the new popup with no base equivalent; label that absence explicitly. Do not edit or check out another lead's worktree to capture the base. Only the lead/capturer may arrange an isolated baseline checkout. Record the actual capture SHA if review changes the head.

## Fixture matrix

| ID | Named fixture and data | Expected render / branch | Diff affected | Evidence | Minimum captures | How to seed | Status |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| F01 | Add, no suggestions | empty; fresh Add, empty fields, not submitted. Same settled layout for missing op, failure, garbage, bad-shape, mixed-invalid. No chevron/popup; revised helper wraps. | Yes | still | DL, DD, NL, ND | Real app; profile empty. Also run missing/failure/garbage/bad-shape/mixed-invalid RPC transcripts; reuse this settled capture. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F02 | Add, suggestions ready, closed | one (or two); empty fields, popup closed; name initially focused. Chevron consumes input trailing space. | Yes | still | DL, DD | Real app; profile one, open Add; wait for result without clicking Account. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F03 | One option, pointer selection | one; open by Account click and trigger, hover then click option. Account+email shown; filled account survives blur; Add persists it. | Yes | recording | DL, DD, NL, ND | Real app; profile one; type Name=Personal, click Account/chevron, choose, save, reopen Edit. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F04 | Two options, keyboard highlight | two; unhighlighted and highlighted rows; ArrowDown/Up, Enter selection, Tab focus. Highlight alone must not replace typed value or save the form. | Yes | recording | DL | Real app; profile two; focus Account, arrows, Enter, Tab. Include trigger close/reopen. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F05 | Unmatched free text with suggestions | two; type custom-team (matches neither), then shorthand/ID variants. Both options stay visible: mode=none, no filtering or no-results branch. Blur preserves custom text. | Yes | recording | DL, NL | Real app; profile two; type unmatched value, blur, submit with valid name, reopen Edit and check exact account. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F06 | Empty email option | blank-email; one account and empty secondary span, no separator/fallback text. | Yes | recording | DL | Real app; profile blank-email; open and select. Missing/null email is a decode failure instead, covered by F01. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F07 | Same address, different emails | same-address; two rows, both acme.1password.com, distinct synthetic emails. No deduplication; rows are keyed by distinct account values. The two selections fill distinct user IDs `SYNTHETIC_U1` / `SYNTHETIC_U2`. | Yes | recording | DL | Real app; profile same-address; open, navigate both rows and select each across reopens. Verify the first and second rows fill SYNTHETIC_U1 and SYNTHETIC_U2 respectively; distinct account-value keys avoid duplicate address keys. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F08 | Long account/email, long Edit title | long; 253-character valid account, long email; 64-character provider label. Both spans truncate; title can wrap. Exercise horizontal caret scrolling and option choice. | Yes | recording | DL, DD, NL, ND | Real app; profile long; Add a 64-character synthetic label and choose long account, then Edit. Long environment-label wrapping is separately named F28. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F09 | Overflow list, top/middle/bottom | many; 20 accounts; list exceeds available height/23rem cap. Scrollbar/gutter and top/bottom fades; last option remains selectable. | Yes | recording | DL, NL | Real app; profile many; open and wheel/touch-scroll through list; select team20. No virtualization/group/disabled-item variants in this use. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F10 | Short viewport, popup collision | many; 844x390, enough content to constrain popup/dialog. Check upward flip or available-height clamping, panel scrolling and footer reachability. | Yes | recording | SL | Real app; profile many; resize before Add, open list and scroll/select. Accept actual collision result rather than hard-coding a popup side. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F11 | Edit, saved account listed | two; existing Personal/my.1password.com; Edit Personal title, Save changes footer; populated Name+Account; popup can replace account with acme.1password.com. | Yes | recording | DL | Real app; profile two; Add Personal once, then Edit, change account, Save changes, reopen. Stable provider ID is retained. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F12 | Edit, saved account unlisted | two; existing Work/custom-team; typed account must survive opening suggestions, highlight, dismissal and save. No persistent selected-item/checkmark branch (selectionMode=none). | Yes | recording | DL | Real app; profile two; Add Work with custom-team, Edit, open/close list, save or replace and reopen. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F13 | Edit, no suggestions | empty or missing op; existing Personal/my.1password.com. Edit footer/title with plain input and changed helper; update manual account. | Yes | recording | NL | Real app; create via F03 first, choose profile empty and reload client, Edit. Missing op produces the same shape without fake op on PATH. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F14 | Submitted, both errors | empty; blank Name+Account, submitted=true. Both alerts, invalid styles, increased height; submit now disabled until valid. | Account wrapper affected; name path inherited | recording | NL, ND | Real app; profile empty; fresh Add then submit blanks, focus each invalid field and correct both. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F15 | Submitted, name-only empty error | two; Name empty, Account valid. Only Name alert; account control retains trigger. | Account wrapper affected; validation inherited | recording | DL | Real app; profile two; choose account without entering name, submit, then correct name. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F16 | Submitted, name-only slug error | empty; Name=!!!, Account=custom-team. Error: name needs at least one letter or digit. | Account wrapper affected; validation inherited | recording | NL | Real app; profile empty; type values, submit, correct name. Name limit 64 remains native input limit. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F17 | Submitted, duplicate-name error | two; saved provider id personal; add another Name=Personal, Account valid. Duplicate-name alert; distinct longer message. | Account wrapper affected; existingIds inherited | recording | NL | Real app; seed Personal through Add or settings RPC, then Add Personal again with profile two and submit. Editing its own ID is allowed (F11). | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F18 | Submitted, account-only empty error | two; Name=Personal, Account blank. Only Account alert; show invalid focused border plus popup, select an account and watch alert clear/submit re-enable. | Yes | recording | DL, DD | Real app; profile two, unique name, submit blank Account; open popup while invalid, choose row, save. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F19 | Submitted, account syntax error | empty; valid Name, Account=https://my.1password.com or a string with spaces. Longer account validation text wraps; manual correction restores validity. | Yes | recording | NL, ND | Real app; profile empty; enter invalid syntax, submit, correct to my.1password.com. Over-253 invalid drafts need a prop/state harness; normal typing/paste is capped (F27). | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F20 | Cold pending to suggestions while typing | delayed; initial query has no data, so no spinner/chevron. Type custom-team before 1.8s response; trigger appears without losing text/focus. Then open list. | Yes | recording | DL | Real app; profile delayed, fresh client/query before opening Add. Start recording before click; include pending, answer, and first popup open. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F21 | Cold timeout to plain input | timeout; fake process delays 60s but driver bounds list at 45s; no loading/error UI, manual field usable before/after response []. | Yes | recording | DL | Real app; profile timeout, fresh client, record continuous real 45s transition and manual typing. Capture RPC completion/log transcript; do not claim timeout from a still. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F22 | Cached suggestions to empty success | first two, then delayed empty; SWR retains old suggestions while pending, successful [] removes trigger/popup. Draft must survive either state. | Yes | recording | DL | Real app; load two, change profile to empty with delayMs=1800. Explicitly refresh onePasswordAccounts via app atom registry driver, or close/reopen after >30s staleTime. Record retained data then empty answer. No automatic polling or refresh button exists in this dialog. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F23 | Cold RPC error, no previous answer | query Failure without previousSuccess; no suggestions/error banner, manual input still usable. Unlike CLI errors, this is an actual RPC/auth/method failure. | Yes | recording | DL | Labelled harness on this VM: real dialog with query boundary returning Failure/no previousSuccess, settings mutation stubbed. Fake op cannot create RPC errors because driver swallows CLI failures. A compatible older server missing only this RPC is an alternative real-app seed. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F24 | RPC error with previous suggestions | query Failure with previousSuccess=two; suggestions and trigger remain; no error banner. Pending/error must not be mistaken for empty success. | Yes | recording | DL | Labelled harness: initialize query Success(two), transition to waiting then Failure retaining previousSuccess. Keep parent editable. Revoking providers-manage through the real parent unmounts dialog instead (G07). | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F25 | Popup dismissal and fresh remount | two; open popup; Escape dismisses it before dialog, outside click within dialog/Tab blur/trigger toggling; Cancel, close X, Escape with popup closed/backdrop dismiss dialog. Reopen starts fresh draft/errors. | Yes (new nested popup); dialog close inherited | recording | DL, NL | Real app; profile two; exercise each dismissal independently, type unsaved text, Cancel/X/Escape/backdrop, reopen Add. Check focus restoration; avoid using only settled screenshots. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F26 | Environment isolation / remote route | A=one (my), B=one (acme); switch environment and open same caller. environmentLabel and returned account must belong to destination, not client host or cached A. | Yes; same visual shape as F03 | recording | DL | On this single-server VM use a labelled environment/query harness keyed by environmentId. Real integration alternative: capturer provisions two isolated environments with fake op separately first on each server PATH, connects over local/remote/relay and selects each via machine scope. Fake op on browser host alone does nothing. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F27 | Manual maximum length and input focus | one; paste/type a 254-character account; native maxLength=253 caps value. Caret/end scroll must leave trigger usable; no spellcheck. Name maxLength=64 unchanged. | Yes; cap preserved in diff | recording | NL | Real app; profile one; paste boundary-length synthetic account, move caret to each end, open trigger, replace with valid value and save. A stale bot description saying the limit was removed is contradicted by this head. | MISSING — no captures yet |
| F28 | Long environment description | environmentLabel=Acme synthetic remote development environment for account-picker proof; existing label 64 characters; long account/email profile. Header description wraps above the same form/popup. | Yes; environmentLabel inherited | recording | NL | Labelled prop harness unless the capturer can configure that synthetic environment label through its normal environment catalog. Mount real Edit dialog with environmentLabel as given, query=long; open popup and check constrained panel/footer. Fake op supplies accounts only and cannot rename the environment. | MISSING — no captures yet |

## Caller gates and unreachable layouts

These unchanged controls explain when the changed component cannot render. They are inventory coverage, not extra mandatory screenshots of unrelated UI. An optional control capture must not substitute for an F row.

| ID | Gate / render branch | How to seed | Diff affected | Evidence if exercised | Minimum | Status |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| G01 | Secrets flag off: route redirects to General, nav/search entry unavailable | Build/start Vite without T3CODE_FEATURE_SECRETS, or set 0; no op stub needed | No | still | No extra capture | NOT CAPTURED — unchanged gate |
| G02 | Disconnected/no usable environment: connect/reconnect message; no dialog mount | Select a disconnected isolated environment; no op response possible | No | still; recording for disconnect during open | No extra capture | NOT CAPTURED — unchanged gate |
| G03 | Connected old server advertises secretProviderSettings!=true: update message | Labelled server-config harness, or genuine old isolated server; fake op does not alter capability | No | still | No extra capture | NOT CAPTURED — unchanged gate |
| G04 | Missing/pending/failed providers-manage access: Add/Edit hidden; no dialog | Restricted scoped session or session harness. Fake op cannot change grant. RPC permission can be verified directly with a denied call/transcript | RPC scope yes; parent UI unchanged | still | No extra visual capture; scope is protocol evidence | NOT CAPTURED — unchanged gate |
| G05 | Project/checkout scope: environment-wide notice, read-only list | Choose a synthetic project/checkout scope in settings; fake op irrelevant because dialog is not mounted | No | still | No extra capture | NOT CAPTURED — unchanged gate |
| G06 | Unsupported kind/invalid existing config, empty provider list, removed editing entry | Empty providers exposes Add; supported entry exposes Edit; unsupported config has Remove only. Seed settings RPC or supported app controls; unknown kind may require settings fixture/harness. Removing editing entry causes no dialog; do not invent an unsupported-provider Edit layout | No | still; recording for entry removal during open | No extra capture | NOT CAPTURED — unchanged gate |
| G07 | Access revoked/connection lost during open: parent becomes read-only and dialog unmounts | Session/environment harness or real isolated session/connection change; fake op alone cannot cause it | New RPC can fail; unmount inherited | recording | No extra capture; differs from F24 retained RPC error | NOT CAPTURED — unchanged gate |

## Seeding the real app on this VM (instructions for the capturer; not executed here)

All prepared files are under `/tmp/lead-31721-r1/proof-audit-1`. The executable `op` accepts only the exact driver invocation `--cache=false account list --format json`; it refuses read/inject/other operations. It reads `profile.json` on every invocation and only prints synthetic JSON; it never contacts 1Password. `fixtures.json` lists raw account arrays. `profiles/` contains ready-to-copy process profiles with stdout, exitCode, delayMs. Default active profile is empty.

Before the future server starts, select a profile, for example:

```sh
cp /tmp/lead-31721-r1/proof-audit-1/profiles/two.json /tmp/lead-31721-r1/proof-audit-1/profile.json
```

From the review checkout, the capturer can start its own isolated server using:

```sh
PATH="/tmp/lead-31721-r1/proof-audit-1:$PATH" T3CODE_DEV_SEED=0 T3CODE_FEATURE_SECRETS=1 vp run dev
```

This command is a proposed capture recipe only; the auditor did **not** start it. Keep worktree-local dev state, never the live userdata directory. Read actual ports from dev-runner output, use its authenticated normal app route, and select environment scope at `/settings/secrets?machine=<environment-id>` (or Settings → Secrets, owning environment scope). There is no need to run a provider agent or read a secret. The flag must reach Vite when it compiles; setting it on only an already-running backend is insufficient. Do not publish credentials/pairing links.

For Add use the Add provider button. For Edit seed by saving a synthetic provider through Add, or send authenticated `server.updateSettings` with this payload to the **isolated selected environment**:

```json
{"secretProviders":{"personal":{"kind":"one_password","label":"Personal","config":{"account":"my.1password.com"}}}}
```

To inspect data without UI use authenticated `server.listOnePasswordAccounts` with `{}` and the `providers:manage` scope. Record returned count/shape and exit/timeout outcomes without auth tokens. Set explicit Appearance light/dark. A driver through the app's existing RPC boundary must use the normal authenticated connection; do not write the live DB.

Changing the profile does not invalidate a cached account query. For cold fixtures, reload the client so its atom registry is new (do not merely close/open rapidly). For deliberate F22 revalidation, use the query atom's refresh in a labelled app driver or close/reopen after it becomes stale; include the transition in the recording. CLI outcomes all become successful [] and do not simulate F23/F24. For missing-op proof start the capturer's isolated server without the fake directory on PATH: this VM has no real op. Switching from missing to fake needs the capturer to restart only the server PID it captured at spawn; profile changes between fake outcomes do not require server restart.

| Profile | Raw process behavior / list | Expected RPC result |
| --- | --- | --- |
| empty | stdout [] | [] |
| one | my.1password.com / me@example.com | One {account,email} |
| two | one + acme.1password.com / me@acme.example | Two, source order |
| blank-email | my.1password.com / empty string | One with email="" |
| same-address | acme.1password.com twice, me@example.com and other@example.com | Two duplicate addresses preserved |
| long | 253-character synthetic address + long synthetic email, plus short Acme | Two; visual truncation/focus stress |
| many | team01 through team20.1password.com, synthetic01 through synthetic20@example.com | Twenty; scrolling |
| failure | valid two-account JSON but exitCode=1 | [] (nonzero exit overrides stdout) |
| garbage | stdout "not json", exitCode=0 | [] |
| bad-shape | object {accounts:[...]} instead of array | [] |
| mixed-invalid | one valid row + an https:// address that fails OnePasswordAccount | [] for entire array, not partial success |
| delayed | two, delayMs=1800 | Pending then two |
| timeout | two, delayMs=60000 | Driver timeout after 45s, [] |
| missing (no profile) | op absent on server PATH | [] |

Additional malformed equivalents (missing/null email, empty URL, non-string fields, JSON null) collapse into F01 and can be checked with one parameterized RPC transcript, without duplicate visual captures. A still cannot identify which backend cause produced []: associate the profile and transcript with its capture.

**Harness-only rows:** F23, F24, F26 and F28 on the stated single-environment VM; optionally unreachable schema-invalid draft lengths. Mount the real SecretProviderDialog with normal dialog/theme/query providers and injected query states/props; label evidence prominently `HARNESS — synthetic query/props`, list injected data and SHA. Stub settings mutation to collect intended payload. Do not build lookalike HTML or portray a mocked RPC error as a server-path capture. In F24 keep parent editable so the intended retained-data state can exist. For F26 give different arrays per environmentId and change caller scope; this proves client cache/routing display only, not actual remote subprocess execution. A real two-environment RPC transcript is needed to make that latter claim.

## Coverage and limits

Read the entire 13-path diff, the single changed component's full JSX, sole caller and access/scope gates, validation, query adapter/SWR/cache behavior, installed Base UI mode behavior, autocomplete/dialog/input/scroll wrappers, feature flag/route, server service/driver/RPC and permission wiring. Refreshed PR description, comments, reviews and status read-only through GitCafe. Existing review text is historical context, not capture evidence. No test/CI claim is substituted for visual proof. No need to run repo-wide checks for this pass.

The plan intentionally collapses identical layouts: cold failures share F01; cached errors share positive shape but require F24 transition proof; no client-side filtered-empty, spinner, grouped/disabled/exhausted-account, separate native-mobile or OS-specific dialog rows are invented. Caller gates are listed separately. Capture against the final head and recheck if render code changes.

FRICTION: none

VERDICT: INSUFFICIENT no captures yet
